Skip to content

Robo Advisor v Financial Advisor: Which is Best?


Effective stewardship of one’s assets can lead to long-term stability and growth. However, successful investing in the modern marketplace remains an impressive accomplishment. Not only is there a complex and global economic environment, but there are always storms to weather. Emerging from those storms to seize growth opportunities is critical, but you must be able to recognize those opportunities.

By Philippe Schneider, Global Head of Sales, DHF Capital

Traditionally, human financial advisors have played a key role in helping investors navigate the complexities of financial markets. With technological advancements, robo-advisors have rapidly emerged as an alternative, using algorithms to manage investments. This article will explore and compare the fundamental characteristics of robo advisors v financial advisors, providing an overview of their respective features and how they fit into the modern investment landscape.

What is a Robo-Advisor?

A robo-advisor is a digital, automated replacement for the human financial advisor. Advanced algorithms designed with market forces and different investment dynamics in mind provide a platform for a more hands-off approach to investing.

Robo-advisors typically build investment profiles for individuals based on initial or periodic questionnaires. These questionnaires explore the investors’ goals, their appetite for risk, and other factors. Using that information, the robo-advisor algorithm engages in automated portfolio management. This process may include selecting investments, rebalancing the portfolio, and many other actions a financial advisor might take on your behalf.

Today, robo-advisors comprise a significant market segment. By 2023, their market was estimated to be worth more than $7 billion. Today’s largest robo-advisory firms manage hundreds of billions of dollars in assets. Their popularity makes them a significant force in the industry. Consider what’s driving the widespread adoption of these tools among investors.

Why Would Someone Choose a Robo-Advisor?

Robo-advisors have a widespread reputation for offering investors a more flexible entry point. Most automated advisors don’t have high minimum asset requirements to start investing. Likewise, the costs and fees associated with robo-advisors are often much lower than those associated with working with a professional. Getting started is simple; even novice investors can build a portfolio with a robo-advisor. For those who don’t have the time to monitor the market or keep up on their investments frequently, robo-advisors offer a reasonable hands-off solution.

With robo-advisors, investors can turn most of the management of their portfolio assets over to the computer. As algorithms continue to improve and systems become more capable of ingesting and analyzing vast volumes of data, robo-advisors may also advance and respond to market conditions. Still, robo-advisors have inherent drawbacks that may make them less suitable for experienced investors or high-net-worth individuals.

Where Robots Might Fall Short

While robo-advisors offer an excellent entry path for beginning and intermediate investors, they may not be the most suitable choice for all investors. Individuals with complex investing requirements or an extensive portfolio of assets to manage may find that robo-advisors aren’t as flexible as they require. Investors with a high net worth or a substantial amount to invest often have more personal needs and goals. Current robo-advisors can’t consider these goals at the same level as a human advisor. They can’t offer tailored advice for your goals and personal financial situation. Likewise, they aren’t adept at structuring very complicated portfolios.

Perhaps most concerning to more active investors is that robo-advisors may come up short when the market enters a period of high volatility. With so much more noise in the data, algorithms may not be able to respond accurately or quickly to rapidly shifting conditions.

Robo Advisor v Financial Advisor: The Place of Traditional Services

Before the advent of modern robo-advisors, human professionals were the primary source of insight into investment strategies. Today, expert financial advisors continue to play a significant role, particularly for those with specific goals or higher net worths. Human advisors offer personalized insight and guidance, allowing for a more tailored approach to portfolio management.

While robo-advisors provide a level of automation and efficiency, they may not quickly adapt strategies or respond to specific immediate requirements. In contrast, personal financial advisors can work closely with clients to set clear guidelines for investment management and can make rapid adjustments during volatile periods. The human touch in investing offers a more personalized approach that may be particularly valuable in times of uncertainty.

Some individuals are drawn to robo-advisors due to certain limitations associated with traditional financial advisors. Human advisors often charge higher fees compared to their automated counterparts. Additionally, many advisory firms require a minimum asset threshold, which could be tens or even hundreds of thousands of dollars. For high-net-worth individuals (HNWIs), these firms provide experience and guidance tailored to navigating the complexities of current and future markets.

Is There a Best of Both Worlds?

There are advantages and disadvantages to relying solely on either robo-advisors or human financial advisors. Increasingly, many firms are offering hybrid robo-advisors, which combine automated portfolio management with access to human advisors. This combination may help in developing a diverse approach to investment management.

As technology continues to evolve, so do robo-advisors. The integration of AI and the ability to analyze large datasets could lead to advanced generations of robo-advisors. These future platforms might leverage extensive historical market data to enhance their functionality. Despite these technological advancements, human insight and creativity remain significant in the realm of investment management.

Forging the Path That’s Right for Your Portfolio

Effectively managing your assets and exploring different investment opportunities can be important steps for your future. Today, robo-advisors provide convenience and time-saving solutions, though they may not offer personalized advice or complex financial planning. For beginners and those with limited capital, robo-advisors can be a great starting point. Personalized financial advice remains highly valuable for individuals with higher net worth, bigger goals, or more specific needs. As technology continues to evolve, relying more on automation tools might become beneficial. However, it’s essential to consider your goals and carefully evaluate each strategy before making decisions on using a robo advisor v financial advisor.

Looking for great investing ideas? Sign up to our free newsletter.

Join us on WhatsApp

This article does not constitute investment advice. Make sure you do your own research or consult a professional advisor.

'How to' Guides

Our latest in-depth company reports

Detailed reviews of selected companies and investment trusts.

On the podcast

Sign up for great investing stock tips

Thanks to our Site Partners

Our partners are established, regulated businesses and we are grateful for their support.

CME Group
FP Markets

Back To Top